Cat wrecked in Kimberley's

Exit Forum › Forums › Kimberley Coast Boating Forum. › General Interest › Cat wrecked in Kimberley's

Viewing 11 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • 03/11/2017 at 4:49 am #2347
      Johnno
      Participant

        Sorry, seems the You Tube channel didn’t work, try again…

        https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDk8eedXBE7Ohnxoa8vilFw

         

      • 21/12/2017 at 1:20 am #2390
        Kaitoro
        Participant

          Where and how?

          It appears this wreck occurred in York Sound and at night. From the videos it appears they hit a reef that was 300m further out than charted.

          Easy to claim travelling at night was too risky but travelling during daylight hours, tho’ safer, is not a guarantee if the water is silty. And, with Zone of Confidence C(4) charting.

          Would be nice to know exactly where this occurred.

          Jeff and Anne-Marie
          SY Kaitoro
          Mumby Cybercat 48
          VJN4817

          • 21/12/2017 at 4:39 am #2391
            Johnno
            Participant

              There has been repeated requests from a number of individuals, including myself, through his blog and Facebook for a position of the grounding but all to no avail.

              If you check out his FB page theirs plenty of requests there but it seems all he is interested in is putting up old video of past times frolicking with the girls, personally (and unfortunately) i’m starting to have doubts about the “uncharted” part of this saga….

              John

          • 21/12/2017 at 11:16 am #2392
            Ross
            Keymaster

              Hi John, I dont like publishing unconfirmed info, but the feedback I’ve received is that the rock is approx 14 47.715S 125 11.186E which is just south of Scott Straight.

              Again, unconfirmed, but I think a degree of scepticism needs to be exercised around this issue. Going by the video, there is no doubt the cat got into trouble, but judging from the youtube and the web posts following that, things become a little harder to understand. This is further emphasized by the owners use of the term “dodgy” in his own web site.

              Click on the photo below. Not somewhere I’d suggest to be sailing at night.

              Ross.

              Attachments:
              You must be logged in to view attached files.
            • 23/12/2017 at 2:12 am #2397
              Kaitoro
              Participant

                Thanks Ross,

                Did you get this from Ray of Dog on Cat?

                “Plukky” replied this morning –

                From: Peter Lukursky <peterlukursky@hotmail.com>
                Subject: Re: [Sailing Into Freedom] Contact
                Date: December 22, 2017 at 04:07:15 MST
                To: Jeff Boyd <jb1947xx@telus.net>

                HI there, I lost all my equipment so I don’t have the rock position but I met Ray? on the catamaran “Dog on Cat” who is always in the area. He knows about the rock cos I confirmed it with him. HE has the coords. P

                Satellite imagery puts this out from a likely looking reef (see attached), in ZoC D(5) water.

                Jeff and Anne-Marie
                SY Kaitoro
                Mumby Cybercat 48
                VJN4817

                Attachments:
                You must be logged in to view attached files.
              • 23/12/2017 at 8:39 am #2399
                Ross
                Keymaster

                  No, I didn’t get it from Ray & Barb. But I know where they are. I’ll try to get in touch with them.

                  Ross

                • 24/12/2017 at 5:28 am #2400
                  Johnno
                  Participant

                    Thanks Ross & Jeff for your efforts,

                    If that position is correct then you have to wonder what they where doing transiting an unsurveyed area at night, which to my mind nullifies the claim of hitting a uncharted rock as basically nothing is charted in the area, the fact that charts state “unsurveyed” is in fact telling you that hazards exist and are present in the area so is in fact “charted”, it’s just the positions are not known, anyhow i’m pretty sure Plucky now realises this and will be beating himself up over it for a while yet.

                    Jeff that email is almost word for word what a friend of mine that works for Paspaley received when he asked the question, and like him i had no idea who Ray of the catamaran “Dog on Cat” was so info is all but useless, my friend replied for clarification but as yet has not received an answer, hopefully Ross gets some news…..

                    John

                  • 25/12/2017 at 8:40 pm #2401
                    carrboyd
                    Participant

                      From Cruiser Forums about “Long Reef”:

                      “Location: Darwin
                      Re: Vloggers hit an uncharted rock/reef in the Kimberleys
                      We were contacted by the Caledonian Sky on 18th August to say they had Peter and Maggie on board and they were docking in Darwin soon. The grounding must have happened about a week prior to that as I believe they spent several days on the cabin roof waiting to be rescued. The area is replete with very large Saltwater crocodiles which are well known for attacking many Cruisers dinghy’s.

                      It is somewhere on the eastern side of York Sound. I think they were heading for a location known as Rainforest Ravine.

                      We didn’t get too much detail on location which is understandable while Peter was looking at salvage options. Our understanding is that they had originally intended to anchor near Cape Pond but that was not suitable and so decided to push on to another anchorage but strong tide against them left them short of daylight hours and trying to come into an anchorage at night.

                      I’m not passing any judgement on the decisions.”

                      Caledonian Sky left Broome 20/7/17 docked Darwin Saturday 19/8/17.

                      -Steve

                    • 26/12/2017 at 2:54 am #2402
                      Johnno
                      Participant

                        Thanks Steve seen that thread, Plucky’s a member at CF but hasn’t replied to any questions as yet.

                        http://www.cruisersforum.com/forums/f2/vloggers-hit-an-uncharted-rock-reef-in-the-kimberleys-193177.html

                        I’ve decided not to get overly concerned with it, just thought it would have been helpful to others if they could mark the location, lots of blank spots up that way so it’s always good when you can fill some in, i’d just hate for some other unfortunate soul to end up in the same situation or worse at the same location.

                        John

                        • This reply was modified 7 years, 4 months ago by Johnno.
                      • 21/03/2024 at 3:03 pm #4150
                        SVDefino
                        Participant

                          Was the position ever confirmed ?

                        • 22/03/2024 at 10:53 am #4154
                          Ross
                          Keymaster

                            Not aware that anyone has confirmed the rock possi. But I saw the wreck on a beach in that area about 4 years ago. Possibly still there. My thoughts – don’t sail at night in the KC close to shore unless you know the area or you’re following a previous safe track. Even then, you have logs and whales that you can’t see.

                            Cheers, Ross

                            • 22/03/2024 at 5:49 pm #4155
                              SVDefino
                              Participant

                                Ok thanks , yeah we are very cautious mariners, I was just wondering if Plucky ever confirmed , he was using his IPad with Navigation so he would have has the mark ,

                            • 25/03/2024 at 7:17 pm #4158
                              Wild Thing
                              Participant

                                I was there in July 2022 I marked the end of the reef gave the lat and long to Bar of Dog on Cat and she sent it off to the Australian hydrographic authorities

                                144.48.667S  125.10.743 E

                                it has about 500 mil of water over it at low tide

                                Russell. WILDTHING

                              • 25/03/2024 at 7:20 pm #4159
                                Wild Thing
                                Participant

                                  I just checked it’s on the latest Navioncs charts

                                  • 27/03/2024 at 2:30 pm #4162
                                    IndigoCat
                                    Participant

                                      Hi

                                      you might want to double check those coordinates – possible typo?

                                      regards

                                      carol and tony

                                      indigo

                                       

                                       

                                    • 27/03/2024 at 10:11 pm #4163
                                      SVDefino
                                      Participant

                                        The dotted lines indicate the reef edge ?

                                        Attachments:
                                        You must be logged in to view attached files.
                                  • Author
                                    Posts
                                  Viewing 11 reply threads
                                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.